xref: /xnu-12377.41.6/tests/sched/contextswitch.c (revision bbb1b6f9e71b8cdde6e5cd6f4841f207dee3d828)
1*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions #include <unistd.h>
2*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions #include <stdio.h>
3*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions #include <stdlib.h>
4*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions #include <pthread.h>
5*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions #include <errno.h>
6*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions #include <err.h>
7*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions #include <string.h>
8*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions #include <assert.h>
9*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions #include <sysexits.h>
10*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions #include <getopt.h>
11*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions #include <spawn.h>
12*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions #include <stdbool.h>
13*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions #include <sys/sysctl.h>
14*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions #include <mach/mach_time.h>
15*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions #include <mach/mach.h>
16*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions #include <mach/semaphore.h>
17*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions #include <TargetConditionals.h>
18*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
19*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions #ifdef T_NAMESPACE
20*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions #undef T_NAMESPACE
21*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions #endif
22*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
23*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions #include <darwintest.h>
24*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions #include <darwintest_utils.h>
25*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions #include <stdatomic.h>
26*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
27*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions #include "sched_test_utils.h"
28*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
29*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions T_GLOBAL_META(T_META_NAMESPACE("xnu.scheduler"),
30*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions     T_META_RADAR_COMPONENT_NAME("xnu"),
31*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions     T_META_RADAR_COMPONENT_VERSION("scheduler"));
32*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
33*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions #define MAX_THREADS     32
34*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions #define SPIN_SECS       6
35*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions #define THR_SPINNER_PRI 63
36*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions #define THR_MANAGER_PRI 62
37*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions #define WARMUP_ITERATIONS 100
38*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions #define POWERCTRL_SUCCESS_STR "Factor1: 1.000000"
39*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
40*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions static semaphore_t semaphore;
41*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions static semaphore_t worker_sem;
42*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions static uint32_t g_numcpus;
43*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions static _Atomic uint32_t keep_going = 1;
44*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions static dt_stat_time_t s;
45*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
46*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions static struct {
47*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	pthread_t thread;
48*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	bool measure_thread;
49*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions } threads[MAX_THREADS];
50*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
51*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions extern char **environ;
52*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
53*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions static void
csw_perf_test_init(void)54*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions csw_perf_test_init(void)
55*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions {
56*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	int spawn_ret, pid;
57*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	char *const clpcctrl_args[] = {"/usr/local/bin/clpcctrl", "-f", "5000", NULL};
58*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	spawn_ret = posix_spawn(&pid, clpcctrl_args[0], NULL, NULL, clpcctrl_args, environ);
59*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	waitpid(pid, &spawn_ret, 0);
60*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions }
61*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
62*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions static void
csw_perf_test_cleanup(void)63*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions csw_perf_test_cleanup(void)
64*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions {
65*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	int spawn_ret, pid;
66*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	char *const clpcctrl_args[] = {"/usr/local/bin/clpcctrl", "-d", NULL};
67*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	spawn_ret = posix_spawn(&pid, clpcctrl_args[0], NULL, NULL, clpcctrl_args, environ);
68*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	waitpid(pid, &spawn_ret, 0);
69*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions }
70*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
71*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions static pthread_t
make_thread(uint32_t thread_id,uint32_t priority,bool fixpri,void * (* start_routine)(void *))72*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions make_thread(uint32_t thread_id, uint32_t priority, bool fixpri,
73*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions     void *(*start_routine)(void *))
74*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions {
75*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	int rv;
76*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	pthread_t new_thread;
77*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	struct sched_param param = { .sched_priority = (int)priority };
78*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	pthread_attr_t attr;
79*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
80*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	T_ASSERT_POSIX_ZERO(pthread_attr_init(&attr), "pthread_attr_init");
81*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
82*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	T_ASSERT_POSIX_ZERO(pthread_attr_setschedparam(&attr, &param),
83*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	    "pthread_attr_setschedparam");
84*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
85*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	if (fixpri) {
86*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		T_ASSERT_POSIX_ZERO(pthread_attr_setschedpolicy(&attr, SCHED_RR),
87*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		    "pthread_attr_setschedpolicy");
88*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	}
89*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
90*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	T_ASSERT_POSIX_ZERO(pthread_create(&new_thread, &attr, start_routine,
91*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	    (void*)(uintptr_t)thread_id), "pthread_create");
92*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
93*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	T_ASSERT_POSIX_ZERO(pthread_attr_destroy(&attr), "pthread_attr_destroy");
94*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
95*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	threads[thread_id].thread = new_thread;
96*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
97*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	return new_thread;
98*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions }
99*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
100*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions /* Spin until a specified number of seconds elapses */
101*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions static void
spin_for_timeout(uint32_t seconds)102*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions spin_for_timeout(uint32_t seconds)
103*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions {
104*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	uint64_t duration       = nanos_to_abs((uint64_t)seconds * NSEC_PER_SEC);
105*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	uint64_t current_time   = mach_absolute_time();
106*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	uint64_t timeout        = duration + current_time;
107*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
108*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	uint64_t spin_count = 0;
109*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
110*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	while (mach_absolute_time() < timeout && atomic_load_explicit(&keep_going,
111*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	    memory_order_relaxed)) {
112*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		spin_count++;
113*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	}
114*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions }
115*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
116*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions static void *
spin_thread(void * arg)117*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions spin_thread(void *arg)
118*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions {
119*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	uint32_t thread_id = (uint32_t) arg;
120*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	char name[30] = "";
121*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
122*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	snprintf(name, sizeof(name), "spin thread %2d", thread_id);
123*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	pthread_setname_np(name);
124*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	T_ASSERT_MACH_SUCCESS(semaphore_wait_signal(semaphore, worker_sem),
125*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	    "semaphore_wait_signal");
126*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	spin_for_timeout(SPIN_SECS);
127*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	return NULL;
128*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions }
129*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
130*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions static void *
thread(void * arg)131*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions thread(void *arg)
132*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions {
133*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	uint32_t thread_id = (uint32_t) arg;
134*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	char name[30] = "";
135*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
136*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	snprintf(name, sizeof(name), "thread %2d", thread_id);
137*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	pthread_setname_np(name);
138*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	T_ASSERT_MACH_SUCCESS(semaphore_wait_signal(semaphore, worker_sem), "semaphore_wait");
139*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
140*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	if (threads[thread_id].measure_thread) {
141*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		for (int i = 0; i < WARMUP_ITERATIONS; i++) {
142*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 			thread_switch(THREAD_NULL, SWITCH_OPTION_NONE, 0);
143*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		}
144*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		T_STAT_MEASURE_LOOP(s) {
145*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 			if (thread_switch(THREAD_NULL, SWITCH_OPTION_NONE, 0)) {
146*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 				T_ASSERT_FAIL("thread_switch");
147*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 			}
148*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		}
149*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		atomic_store_explicit(&keep_going, 0, memory_order_relaxed);
150*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	} else {
151*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		while (atomic_load_explicit(&keep_going, memory_order_relaxed)) {
152*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 			if (thread_switch(THREAD_NULL, SWITCH_OPTION_NONE, 0)) {
153*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 				T_ASSERT_FAIL("thread_switch");
154*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 			}
155*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		}
156*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	}
157*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	return NULL;
158*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions }
159*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
160*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions void
check_device_temperature(void)161*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions check_device_temperature(void)
162*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions {
163*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	char buffer[256];
164*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	FILE *pipe = popen("powerctrl Factor1", "r");
165*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
166*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	if (pipe == NULL) {
167*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		T_FAIL("Failed to check device temperature");
168*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		T_END;
169*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	}
170*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
171*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	fgets(buffer, sizeof(buffer), pipe);
172*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
173*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	if (strncmp(POWERCTRL_SUCCESS_STR, buffer, strlen(POWERCTRL_SUCCESS_STR))) {
174*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		T_PERF("temperature", 0.0, "factor", "device temperature");
175*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	} else {
176*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		T_PASS("Device temperature check pass");
177*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		T_PERF("temperature", 1.0, "factor", "device temperature");
178*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	}
179*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	pclose(pipe);
180*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions }
181*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
182*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions void
record_perfcontrol_stats(const char * sysctlname,const char * units,const char * info)183*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions record_perfcontrol_stats(const char *sysctlname, const char *units, const char *info)
184*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions {
185*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	int data = 0;
186*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	size_t data_size = sizeof(data);
187*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	T_ASSERT_POSIX_ZERO(sysctlbyname(sysctlname,
188*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	    &data, &data_size, NULL, 0),
189*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	    "%s", sysctlname);
190*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	T_PERF(info, data, units, info);
191*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions }
192*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
193*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions /* Disable the test on MacOS for now */
194*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions T_DECL(perf_csw, "context switch performance", T_META_TAG_PERF, T_META_CHECK_LEAKS(false), T_META_ASROOT(true), T_META_TAG_VM_NOT_ELIGIBLE)
195*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions {
196*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions #if !defined(__arm64__)
197*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	T_SKIP("Not supported on Intel platforms");
198*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	return;
199*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions #endif /* !defined(__arm64__) */
200*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	check_device_temperature();
201*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
202*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	T_ATEND(csw_perf_test_cleanup);
203*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
204*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	csw_perf_test_init();
205*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	pthread_setname_np("main thread");
206*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
207*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	struct sched_param param = {.sched_priority = 48};
208*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
209*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	T_ASSERT_POSIX_ZERO(pthread_setschedparam(pthread_self(), SCHED_FIFO, &param),
210*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	    "pthread_setschedparam");
211*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
212*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	T_ASSERT_MACH_SUCCESS(semaphore_create(mach_task_self(), &semaphore,
213*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	    SYNC_POLICY_FIFO, 0), "semaphore_create");
214*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
215*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	T_ASSERT_MACH_SUCCESS(semaphore_create(mach_task_self(), &worker_sem,
216*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	    SYNC_POLICY_FIFO, 0), "semaphore_create");
217*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
218*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	g_numcpus = (uint32_t)dt_ncpu();
219*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	printf("hw.ncpu: %d\n", g_numcpus);
220*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	uint32_t n_spinners = g_numcpus - 1;
221*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
222*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	int mt_supported = 0;
223*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	size_t mt_supported_size = sizeof(mt_supported);
224*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	T_ASSERT_POSIX_ZERO(sysctlbyname("kern.monotonic.supported", &mt_supported,
225*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	    &mt_supported_size, NULL, 0), "sysctlbyname kern.monotonic.supported");
226*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
227*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	for (uint32_t thread_id = 0; thread_id < n_spinners; thread_id++) {
228*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		threads[thread_id].thread = make_thread(thread_id, THR_SPINNER_PRI,
229*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		    true, &spin_thread);
230*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	}
231*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
232*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	s = dt_stat_time_create("context switch time");
233*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
234*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	make_thread(n_spinners, THR_MANAGER_PRI, true, &thread);
235*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	threads[n_spinners].measure_thread = true;
236*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	make_thread(n_spinners + 1, THR_MANAGER_PRI, true, &thread);
237*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
238*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	/* Allow the context switch threads to get into sem_wait() */
239*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	for (uint32_t thread_id = 0; thread_id < n_spinners + 2; thread_id++) {
240*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		T_ASSERT_MACH_SUCCESS(semaphore_wait(worker_sem), "semaphore_wait");
241*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	}
242*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
243*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	int enable_callout_stats = 1;
244*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	size_t enable_size = sizeof(enable_callout_stats);
245*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
246*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	if (mt_supported) {
247*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		/* Enable callout stat collection */
248*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		T_ASSERT_POSIX_ZERO(sysctlbyname("kern.perfcontrol_callout.stats_enabled",
249*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		    NULL, 0, &enable_callout_stats, enable_size),
250*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		    "sysctlbyname kern.perfcontrol_callout.stats_enabled");
251*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	}
252*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
253*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	T_ASSERT_MACH_SUCCESS(semaphore_signal_all(semaphore), "semaphore_signal");
254*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
255*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
256*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	for (uint32_t thread_id = 0; thread_id < n_spinners + 2; thread_id++) {
257*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		T_ASSERT_POSIX_ZERO(pthread_join(threads[thread_id].thread, NULL),
258*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		    "pthread_join %d", thread_id);
259*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	}
260*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
261*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	if (mt_supported) {
262*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		record_perfcontrol_stats("kern.perfcontrol_callout.oncore_instr",
263*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		    "instructions", "oncore.instructions");
264*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		record_perfcontrol_stats("kern.perfcontrol_callout.offcore_instr",
265*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		    "instructions", "offcore.instructions");
266*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		record_perfcontrol_stats("kern.perfcontrol_callout.oncore_cycles",
267*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		    "cycles", "oncore.cycles");
268*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		record_perfcontrol_stats("kern.perfcontrol_callout.offcore_cycles",
269*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		    "cycles", "offcore.cycles");
270*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
271*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		/* Disable callout stat collection */
272*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		enable_callout_stats = 0;
273*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		T_ASSERT_POSIX_ZERO(sysctlbyname("kern.perfcontrol_callout.stats_enabled",
274*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		    NULL, 0, &enable_callout_stats, enable_size),
275*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 		    "sysctlbyname kern.perfcontrol_callout.stats_enabled");
276*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	}
277*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 
278*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	check_device_temperature();
279*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions 	dt_stat_finalize(s);
280*bbb1b6f9SApple OSS Distributions }
281